To Avoid Permanent Leviathan, People Must Reclaim their Rights

A recent article in The Economist raises an important issue with respect to the coronavirus outbreak. A big government may well be needed to fight the pandemic, but how will it shrink back once the pandemic crisis is over? “The state must act decisively. But history suggests that after crises the state does not give up all the ground it has taken.”

In Crisis and Leviathan, Robert Higgs explains how crisis after crisis, the U.S. government increases in either size or regulatory reach. When a crisis occurs, there is a demand for the government to “do something.” Responding to this demand, governments increase their size and regulatory outreach. However, once the crisis is over, spending and regulation do not go back to their initial levels. The result is an increase in government size and regulatory reach from one crisis to the next. 

The “coronavirus” pandemic has changed the world in a matter of weeks. Countries around the world are mandating lockdowns and “stay-in-home” orders. In some cases, as in my home country Argentina, citizens abroad are not allowed to re-enter their home countries. There is a risk that whatever justified measures governments are taking because of the pandemic outbreak will remain as unjustified powers once the pandemic crisis is over.

We should be careful about learning the wrong lessons from this event. For instance, that the lack of health resources is due to the greed of health providers overlooking the effect of inefficient and excessive regulation. 

Or, like in Argentina, that the government has the right to suspend constitutional rights; is it legitimate for a government to forbid the return of citizens to their home countries? In short, we should be careful of providing unsound justification for a police state. It does not follow from being acceptable for the government to do something that anything is acceptable.

Look at the figure below, which shows the idea behind the ratchet effect. The horizontal axis tracks time. The vertical axis measures the size and regulatory reach of the government. The first two crises show an increase in government powers. The third crisis, which represents the coronavirus outbreak, shows a significantly larger increase in government size (bailouts, spending programs, etc.) and regulatory powers. The wrong arguments in favor of a police state during the coronavirus crisis can lead to a larger state once the pandemic outbreak is over.

There is a substantial difference between having a small government that is ready to act if needed in the case of an emergency (war, pandemics, etc.) and having a government that is always with state-of-emergency powers. Societies around the world have granted their governments powers to do whatever is needed. The same societies should forcefully reclaim those rights once the crisis is over. 

Published by

Henry Clay’s “American System” Is Bad News for the American Economy

"The American System's modern rehabilitators conveniently leave out the fact that every time it was… Read More

December 8, 2022

The Libido for the Superficial

"Once the reality of a libido for the superficial is admitted, many phenomena are better… Read More

December 8, 2022

Average Weekly Initial Claims Hits the Highest Level Since September

“Rising weekly initial claims and increasing job cut announcements may signal some labor market softening.… Read More

December 8, 2022

How Our Higher Education System Could Put Students First

"I fear that LeBlanc underestimates the ability of the educational status quo to fend off… Read More

December 8, 2022

Markets Feed the Poor, Government Creates Them – The Misguided Economics of Pope Francis

"We should be wary of eating the seed corn – but also wary of killing… Read More

December 7, 2022

How Yellowstone Portrays the American Creed

"The success of the Dutton family depicts the best parts of capitalism (a system based… Read More

December 7, 2022

Congress Can Restore the Integrity of the Dollar

"The historical record is clear: Gold-backed money is fully capable of delivering short-run stability and… Read More

December 7, 2022

Forgetful Fauci’s Deposition: All Those Lies Are Hard to Keep Straight

"Fauci’s evasions leave us with more questions than answers - and more clues that he… Read More

December 6, 2022

*AIER is a 501(c)(3) Nonprofit registered in the US under EIN:04-2121305