Political Preferences and Public Policy

Social scientists who study elections tend to assume that voters have public policy preferences and that parties and candidates design their platforms to conform with those preferences. In fact, the direction of causation (mostly) goes the other way. Members of the political elite draw up their platforms, and voters adopt the policy preferences of those candidates and parties.

Public policy issues are numerous and often complex, with compelling arguments on all sides. Meanwhile, citizens and voters, as individuals, have no influence over public policy outcomes, so they have little incentive to become informed.

Voters know that their one individual vote will have no influence over an election outcome. Think about this yourself. If you had voted for Joe Biden for president in the last election, who would be president today? If you had voted for Donald Trump, who would be president? And if you didn’t vote in the election, who would be president? The answer to all those questions is Joe Biden.

Realizing that their one vote will have no influence over public policy, voters vote for candidates and parties that make them feel good about themselves rather than considering whether the policies those candidates and parties support are good policies. If their friends or family members support a candidate, people get a good feeling of group solidarity by supporting that candidate. If voters think of themselves as having a certain ideology or political orientation, they will vote that way to reinforce that political identity.

Citizens and voters anchor on political identity. It might be a party, a candidate, or an ideology. Most of their political preferences are then derivative of that identity. People don’t think: I support a woman’s right to have an abortion, I support more gun control, I believe the government should be more involved in health care, and I think impediments to voting should be relaxed. Therefore, I am a Democrat. The reasoning goes the other way. People identify as Democrats; therefore, they support a woman’s right to have an abortion, more gun control, and so forth.

Citizens and voters adapt their public policy preferences from the political elite–the people who actually determine public policy. One implication is that citizens and voters have less influence over public policy than a romantic notion of democracy would suggest. The political elite tells voters what to think, and they fall in line behind their leaders.

For those who are interested in reading more, an extended version of this line of reasoning, written for an academic audience, can be found here.

Reprinted from the Independent Institute

Published by

All Costs Considered

"When facing calls to 'do something' no matter the cost, we must remember that there… Read More

May 21, 2022

Lost Horizon

"National Geographic once represented the open mind and questing heart of classical liberalism at its… Read More

May 21, 2022

Superstitious Storytellers

"Unfortunately, human progress isn’t linear. Faced with the failure of one narrative, or the hypocrisy… Read More

May 20, 2022

Many Workers May Never Return to the Office, and That’s a Good Thing

"It seems safe to predict that the percentage of white-collar workers reporting to their workplace… Read More

May 20, 2022

Let’s Cancel Student Loans – Not Forgive Them, But Cancel the Program

"Higher education in the US is bloated and dysfunctional because federal meddling turned it into… Read More

May 20, 2022

Video: Who Is to Blame for Inflation?

"Is 'Putin's Price Hike' real? Are supply chain disturbances the most significant source of inflation,… Read More

May 20, 2022

Housing Activity Shows More Signs of Deterioration

“Existing-home sales fell again in April and inventory rose, though it remains low by historical… Read More

May 19, 2022

The Lesson of Joe Biden’s Disappearing Presidency

"Despite allegedly being the most powerful person in the world, Presidents frequently find that events… Read More

May 19, 2022

*AIER is a 501(c)(3) Nonprofit registered in the US under EIN:04-2121305