Home Research Commentaries The Global Reach of the Subprime Crisis
The Global Reach of the Subprime Crisis PDF Print E-mail
Written by R.D. Norton   
Friday, 25 April 2008 09:00
This month could be considered the one-year anniversary of the onset of the subprime meltdown. A few pivotal events occurred in April of 2007, before the conflagration that flared up in August. Now, one year on, write-downs on assets exceed $235 billion. This is the sum of the write-downs for the 20 financial institutions that have taken the largest hits on their balance sheets, as listed in the first chart. By write-downs, we mean admissions by the firms themselves that assets they owned in the form of mortgage-backed securities had fallen in value. Why? The original mortgages had been written to people who for whatever reason would stop making their payments, thereby making the downstream securities worth less—sometimes much less.

 

 

The first chart also shows the extent to which subprime pain (largely originating in the U.S.) has registered around the world. True, of the five firms with the largest write-downs, four were American (the exception, spectacularly, was the Union Bank of Switzerland). But 12 of the top 20 were foreign, and they accounted for $107 billion in write-downs (vs. $128 billion for the 8 U.S. firms).

The implication is that financial markets, in all their exotic nuances and modulations, have become more globalized than ever.

What do the write-downs mean for the profitability (and even the viability) of the financial institutions in question?

The answer is less obvious than one might think. For simplicity, the second chart lists only U.S. firms, but the same logic extends to the other dozen as well. It shows that firms can take big hits on their balance sheets while still managing to register positive earnings. Examples are Wachovia, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, and Bank of America. The reason: asset write-downs are a “charge” against earnings. If earnings are strong enough from operations, earnings (profits) can dominate the loss from write-downs, and the net effect can be positive.

 

On the other hand, for (the former) Bear Stearns, Washington Mutual, Merrill Lynch, and Citigroup, write-downs have overpowered whatever positive earnings were generated by ongoing operations over the past year or so.

Have all the write-downs now been acknowledged? Stay tuned. By some reckoning, the total will approach $400 billion, still a far cry from the $235 billion reported so far by the 20 firms that have owned up to the most pain.

As events unfold, it should prove interesting to see how big future write-downs will be in financial institutions outside the U.S., relative to American firms.

 
Comments (2)
more to come
2 Friday, 25 April 2008 18:48
Charles
It's not simply going to be the case of putting a new layer of linoleum down--the sub-floor is rotten.

However, the quicker the writedowns occur, the quicker the system will heal. The Japanese banks refused to acknowledge their losses, and the system langusihed for a decade or so.
Why
1 Friday, 25 April 2008 16:29
???
Why had the mortgage back securties fallen in value?
Why did individuals for "whatever reason" fail to make a payment?

Deregulation beginning in the Regan era, continuing with Clinton? Are you suggesting this was not expected?

Add your comment

Your name:
Your email:
Subject:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification:

About AIER

AIER CastleAmerican Institute for Economic Research (AIER) conducts independent, scientific, economic research to educate individuals, thereby advancing their personal interests and those of the Nation.

Become a Member

Become a Member

An annual sustaining membership entitles you to 22 issues of our Research Reports, which is published twice a month, and to our monthly Economic Education Bulletin, which will vary in length from a four-page letter to more than a 150-page book, depending upon the topic. A digital sustaining membership entitles you to 22 email alerts with links to the latest Research Reports, special sales and coupons, and headlines from Research Commentaries. These alerts come free with an annual sustaining membership.

Shop Online

Shop OnlineWith over 40 publications available, our bookstore has everything you need when you're looking for answers to important personal finance and economic issues. Our all-time bestseller, How to Avoid Financial Tangles, provides solutions to questions ranging from "Do you know how to title property" to "Do you know what financial records you should keep?." Other titles include How to Choose Retirement Housing, The Estate Plan Book, How to Invest Wisely, and What You Need to Know About Social Security.

Affiliates

Progress Foundation

Progress Foundation is AIER’s sister organization located in Zurich, Switzerland. Like AIER, Progress Foundation was founded by E.C. Harwood and serves the public by conducting and disseminating independent research that foster greater understanding of the factors that contribute to human progress.

American Investment Services, wholly-owned by AIER, is registered with the SEC under the Investment Advisors Act of 1940. AIS shares AIER’s facilities and applies AIER’s fundamental research procedures and findings. Follow the link to learn more about AIS’s diversified, disciplined, and cost effective investment management approach.

Make a Donation
 
Become a Member

Login or Create an Account

Why register?

It's free and you'll gain the ability to easily make forum posts, comment on recent articles, track your order history, and receive an email alert when a new Research Commentary is published.

Create an Account

Cost of Living Calculator

Bookstore Sales

Poolside Prosperity Package

© 2008 American Institute for Economic Research. All rights reserved.