Gold Prices in Recessions—Is This Time Different? PDF Print E-mail
Written by Pat Norton   
Monday, 12 January 2009 00:00
Some observers expect gold prices to rise in the coming months, despite the recession.

As the first chart shows, normally gold prices tend to fall during U.S. recessions, as marked by the shaded areas. (The "monthly" average price for January 2009 is actually for January 7.) The tendency is far from uniform, however. In the back-to-back recessions of 1980 and 1982, the price first plunged, then rebounded just as sharply. In the recessions of the early 1990s and 9/11, gold prices hardly moved.

Gold PRices Tend to Fall in US Recessions

Gold prices can be expected to fall during recessions because gold plays a role as a hedge against inflation. When the general price level rises rapidly, a “flight from paper money” can push gold prices up. Since recessions tend to damp inflation, gold prices should come back down. But the ragged pattern in the first chart suggests that there is more to the story.

For starters, in this as in earlier recessions, gold prices do not fall as far or fast as other commodity prices. A case in point in this recession is the plummeting of oil prices from $145 a barrel to around $40. The current price of gold, about $840 a troy ounce, is down only about 20 percent from its spike above $1,000 last March, when Bear Stearns collapsed.

Why this disparity between gold and other commodity prices? And why the “double pump” in gold prices today and in the recessions of the early 1980s? When governments combat recessions (e.g., in Barack Obama’s new administration), budget deficits and easy money may ignite new inflationary fears. This in itself could restore the demand for gold.

A related influence may play out in currency markets. Today as in the early 1980s, uncertainty about the role and value of the dollar may stimulate demand for gold, raising its price relative to other commodities. 

The chart below shows  that the “real” price of gold today is about the same as it was 20 or 25 years ago. The chart compares indexes of gold prices and the general price level (the consumer price index). Beginning some 20 years ago, as inflation was brought under control, gold prices lagged far behind the increase in prices generally.  

The Gold Price Index has Caught the CPI

Only in this decade, following the steady rise in gold’s price after 2000 (as spurred by the rise of gold-hungry India and China), has it caught up with the general price level.  

As markets adapt to the spiraling federal deficit and growing fear of a run against the dollar, gold prices may once again rise faster than the general price level. If so, there could be an upside to gold prices in the next year or so. 

Share this article:

Deli.cio.us    Digg    reddit    Facebook    StumbleUpon    Newsvine
 

Other articles by Pat Norton:

Comments (4)
Gold Prices
4 Wednesday, 21 January 2009 10:55
FrankC
The chart does not reflect a prolonged recession and no one knows how long it will last. I do believe that inflation will follow as we try to get control of the tremendous debt that will be incurred to reflate the economy.
God Price
3 Tuesday, 13 January 2009 14:05
HalJett
I understand the way that gold falls during a recession most of the time, but like you say there are multiple factors. But what happens during a depression? I can't help but look at where we are currently and all that dire talk by the FED about needing extra money to bailout banks (buyout) and all the other failing big companies and not think that we are heading into a depression. Scares me, frankly. And plus there's a lot of talk about price manipulation going on with gold so it's hard to know who to trust or believe. I'm tracking gold and silver right now with http://www.learcapital.com/exactprice and it shows that gold is at $821.50 and ounce and silver $10.77. Both dropped yesterday quite a bit because the dollar seemed strong (I have no idea why it is still so strong with all the bad news).

I still think it's a good investment long term and like you think it will be swinging up this year retesting last year's highs.
That gold price slump in the 1990s
2 Monday, 12 January 2009 14:12
KatyDee
I don't believe India and China demand are the only market factors affecting the recent rise in the gold price. I think, rather, that the reason for the 1990s gold-price slump is that the markets fell for the "Reagan Revolution Illusion" and actually started to believe that central banks can manipulate prices. Today, with bubbles bursting and monetary printing presses churning full blast, people are waking up to the fact that governments are not even bothering to jawbone anymore, and are back to to their usual inflationary shenanigans, the extent of which gold is the barometer.
Gld Price
1 Monday, 12 January 2009 10:41
Ramnarayan
Well, its retailing currently at $39.60 singapore dollars per gram for a 22k 916 gold. of course, am talking about ornaments without making charges. I was shocked actually, as just a while ago, it was $40.80, then it dropped to $39.60, all in Singapore dollars.

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification: